Reading time: 10 minutes

Introduction

In my coaching, I hear a lot about environments where communication is dominated by the loudest voice in the room. There is no coaching 1:1 program not to touch the topic of listening. Similarly, I have not yet known a manager who does not have the explicit desire to improve their communication skills, irrespective of their position or role in the organization.

In his enlightening book 'How to Listen', Oscar Trimboli articulates a powerful idea: effective listening transcends mere comprehension of others' words. It embodies a readiness to allow those words to transform your perspective. This concept revolutionizes the traditional view of listening from a passive activity to an active, intentional pursuit.

As a listener, you approach conversations with a conscious expectation and openness to the idea that these interactions will bring about a meaningful shift in your thought processes and decision-making.

However, in the sphere of management, several misconceptions about listening persist, hindering effective leadership and team cohesion. Here are five prevalent wrong beliefs:

• Listening Is Passive: Many believe that listening is merely about hearing words without active engagement, but true listening involves mental and emotional involvement.
• Understanding Is Automatic: The assumption that a good listener grasps everything immediately ignores the nuances and deeper meanings that can only be comprehended through thoughtful engagement.
• One-Size-Fits-All: This belief underestimates the importance of adapting listening styles to different contexts and individuals, which is crucial in management.
• Innate, Not Learned: Contrary to the belief that effective listening is an inherent skill, it is a capacity that can and should be developed and refined. And this article will show you how.
• Secondary to Speaking: In leadership, the emphasis is often disproportionately placed on articulating thoughts, overshadowing the critical role of listening in garnering diverse perspectives and insights.

In this issue, we delve into the depths of active listening as elucidated by Stromboli, dissecting its levels and exploring how each can be mastered and implemented in various managerial roles. We will dismantle these misconceptions and illuminate the path to becoming not just a manager who hears, but one who truly listens.

Level 1 - Listen to yourself

Your journey toward mastering listening starts with YOU. At this fundamental level, the focus is on your readiness to embrace communication and on maintaining an attentive focus. As a manager, your initial step is to prepare yourself mentally to really listen, a process that demands conscious effort and self-awareness.

Before entering any conversation, particularly in a managerial role, it's essential to adopt a state of openness. This involves setting your personal agenda aside, suspending judgments, and momentarily forgetting your role as a solution-maker or decision-maker. The aim is to create a mental space where you're genuinely receptive to new perspectives and ideas.

With your mindset aligned, the next step is to devote your complete attention to the speaker. Engage actively with what is being communicated, both through words and non-verbal cues. Paying attention is more than just hearing words; it involves being fully present and noticing body language, tone, and other subtle signals. Both yours and of the person(s) you talk to. This level of attentiveness shows your discussion partners that their contributions are valued, cultivating a climate of trust and openness.

At this initial stage, it's crucial to remember that listening is a dynamic process. It's not about waiting for your chance to speak or planning your reply while your communication partner is still speaking. Rather, it's an engaged silence where you're absorbing and contemplating the information, allowing yourself to be influenced and enlightened by what you're hearing.

How does this happen in practice? Imagine a CEO, amidst intense job pressure, who is preparing for a crucial presentation. Despite feeling hungry, he decides to skip a meal and use that time to further prepare for the presentation. His energy levels dipped during the presentation, affecting his ability to think clearly and articulate his points. His usual charisma and sharpness are missing, leading to a dull and unconvincing delivery. Unfortunately for the CEO, he is not able to convince his key stakeholders who refuse to buy into the CEO’s plan.

In real life, these cases are too many. The CEO's choice to ignore his basic needs results not only in a personal disconnect leading him to embrace the idea that a skipped meal has no importance, but also in a professional setback, demonstrating how minor oversights can lead to larger repercussions in high-stakes environments.

The most prevalent challenge at level 1 is being hijacked by emotions or thoughts, becoming absorbed, and getting distracted by external elements or internal thoughts. Such distractions can result in overlooking vital information or misconstruing the speaker's intentions. As a manager, recognizing, accepting to reduce, and reducing these distractions is crucial for ensuring effective communication.

Level 2 - Content: Hear, See, and Sense

At the second level of listening, the focus shifts to understanding both the verbal and non-verbal cues in communication. This level is about more than just the words spoken; it involves perceiving the complete message by integrating what is heard, seen and sensed.

Let’s take the case of a middle manager. In this role, you often find in situations where interpreting team feedback is crucial. This level of listening requires you to pay close attention not only to what your team members are saying but also to how they are saying it. Are their words in sync with their body language? Does their tone match the content of their message? Observing these subtleties can provide a fuller understanding of the team's true sentiments and concerns.

Non-verbal cues like facial expressions, gestures, and posture can sometimes convey more than words. For instance, a team member might verbally agree to a deadline but their hesitant body language or tone of voice could indicate underlying concerns or doubts. Recognizing these cues is vital for a project or middle manager to address unspoken issues effectively and bring out things that need to be immediately addressed or tackled.

This level of listening is a delicate balance between hearing the explicit words and sensing the implicit messages. It involves active engagement with both the audible and the visual aspects of communication. This dual focus helps in gaining a more comprehensive understanding of the situation at hand.

The challenges at this level often include missing key non-verbal cues or misinterpreting spoken information due to distractions or personal biases. It's easy to misread a situation if you're not fully attentive or if preconceived notions cloud your judgment. Being aware of these potential pitfalls is crucial for a manager to ensure an accurate and empathetic understanding of team communications.

Level 3 - Context Explore the Backstory and Notice How It Is Said

The third level of listening delves into the context of communication, focusing on the backstory and the manner in which information is conveyed. This level is pivotal for a deeper, nuanced understanding of interactions, especially for senior managers who need to discern the subtler implications of team dynamics and discussions.

At this level, listening extends beyond the immediate conversation to encompass the broader situational and relational context. As a senior manager, it becomes crucial to understand not just what is being said, but why it is being said in a particular way. This might involve considering historical team dynamics, individual personalities, and the specific circumstances surrounding the communication. For instance, a team’s reluctance to embrace change might be rooted in past experiences rather than the current situation, requiring a different approach from management.

This stage of listening requires a heightened sensitivity to nuances in communication. How a message is delivered – its tone, the choice of words, the timing – can reveal as much as the message itself. A senior manager needs to be attuned to these subtleties to fully grasp the underlying sentiments and motivations of their team.

Let’s consider a senior manager at a software development firm, who faces a challenge. His team, once highly efficient and innovative, has been showing signs of disengagement and low morale. During meetings, team members are reserved, and their usual enthusiasm for new projects has dwindled. The manager is determined to address this issue but relies solely on direct communication during formal meetings to assess the situation.

In a recent team meeting, our manager noticed that when discussing an upcoming project, several team members seemed hesitant. They agreed to the deadlines verbally, but their tone was unenthusiastic. He interpreted this as mere tiredness and proceeded to finalize the project timelines without delving deeper.

Our manager failed to consider the team's history and the context of their responses. Six months earlier, a similar project had led to burnout in a couple of colleagues and to many project issues due to missing resources and consequent quality problems. The team's current hesitance was not just about the new project but also a reflection of their past experiences.

Exploring the backstory involves looking beyond the surface-level conversation and considering the historical and emotional undercurrents that influence communication. It's about connecting the dots between past interactions, present dialogues, and potential future implications. This understanding can be pivotal in resolving conflicts, building team cohesion, and steering the team effectively.

A potential pitfall at this level is the failure to appreciate the significance of context. This oversight can lead to misinterpretations and misunderstandings, as the manager might respond to the immediate content without considering the broader implications. It requires a deliberate effort to step back and view the conversation within a larger frame of reference.

Level 4 - Focus On What Is Unsaid

The fourth level of listening revolves around the subtleties of what remains unsaid in communication. This level requires a perceptive understanding of the unspoken elements, which often hold critical insights, especially in high-stakes environments such as strategic meetings led by CEOs.

At this advanced level of listening, leaders must become adept at interpreting the meaning behind absent information, silence or hesitation. These pauses can be as informative as the words themselves, often indicating uncertainty, disagreement, or the need for further reflection. For example, in a strategic meeting, if a proposal is met with prolonged silence or hesitant responses from key team members, it might signal underlying concerns or disagreements that are not being openly expressed.

This level of listening extends to picking up on subtle cues that indicate hidden agendas or unexpressed concerns. In the realm of executive decision-making, what is not said can sometimes carry more weight than the overt dialogue. A C-suite or a senior manager must be attuned to these nuances, recognizing when team members might be holding back opinions or concerns due to various reasons, such as organizational hierarchy or perceived risks in voicing dissent.

Listening at this level is akin to reading between the lines. It involves a keen awareness of the emotional undercurrents and unspoken dynamics within a conversation. This might include paying attention to body language, the choice of words, and what should have obviously been present in communication but is deliberately left out of the conversation.

One of the key challenges at this level is the failure to acknowledge the significance of what is not being said. This oversight can lead to incomplete understanding and misinformed decisions. It's crucial for leaders to cultivate an awareness that goes beyond the spoken word, recognizing that silence of missing words or ideas in communication subtlety can often reveal more than direct statements.

Level 5 - Listen for (Their) Meaning

At the pinnacle of the listening hierarchy lies Level 5, where the focus is on interpreting the underlying intentions or motivations behind communication. This advanced level of listening is about discerning the deeper meaning, often hidden beneath the surface of the words spoken.

For a senior manager, this level of listening is pivotal in uncovering the real issues that may be affecting team performance or morale. It involves an intuitive understanding of not just what team members are saying, but why they are saying it. This could mean discerning the difference between a team member's expressed satisfaction with a project and their unspoken concerns about workload or resource allocation.

Listening for meaning requires deep empathy and an ability to connect with the speaker on a more profound level. It’s about understanding the emotions, values, and beliefs that drive their communication. For instance, when a team member expresses concern over a deadline, the senior manager must listen beyond the immediate worry to understand the underlying factors – it could be a matter of personal values like quality of work, tendency for perfection, rigidity for certain standards or it can be deeper concerns about team capacity.

This level demands a high degree of emotional intelligence. It requires the listener to be in tune with their own emotions and capable of recognizing and responding to the emotions of others. This sensitivity allows the manager to respond not just to the explicit content of the message, but to the emotional subtext that accompanies it.

A common failure at this level is settling for a superficial understanding of communication. When managers don't probe beyond the surface, they risk responding with surface-level solutions that fail to address the core issues. This can lead to repeated problems that can turn into systemic issues in time, and a sense of disconnect between management and the team.

Overcoming Listening Barriers Through Coaching

As we have explored the various levels of listening, it's evident that each stage presents its unique challenges and potential pitfalls. Overcoming these barriers is not just a matter of awareness but requires deliberate practice and refinement of skills. This is where coaching plays a crucial role in transforming managers into effective listeners.

Coaching provides a structured and supportive environment where managers can learn to recognize and address potential listening failures. It offers personalized feedback and practical strategies to improve listening at each level.

Through coaching, you can practice active listening, learn to interpret non-verbal cues more accurately, understand the context of conversations, and appreciate the unsaid and deeper meanings in communication. And very importantly, learn about who you are in those listening and communication instances.

Improved listening skills have a transformative impact on leadership effectiveness. Leaders who listen well are better equipped to understand and motivate their teams, make informed decisions, and foster a culture of open communication and mutual respect. They become more than just decision-makers; they become empathetic and insightful leaders who can genuinely connect with their teams and lead them towards shared goals.

As you reflect on your listening skills, consider the areas where you might face challenges.

• Are you fully present in your conversations, or do you find your mind wandering? 
• Are you letting yourself be distracted by your emotions or thoughts or maintaining focus with ease?
• Do you struggle to interpret non-verbal cues or to understand the deeper meanings behind what is being said? 
• Do you seem to never have the big picture enough and always experience an incomplete assessment because of that?
• Acknowledge these challenges as opportunities for growth. 

If you want to make a significant step forward in 2024, I invite you to meet 1:1 and see how can we enhance your listening skills. Your next half a year can make a difference in your listening skills. Departing from pragmatic situations in your job, we are going to strengthen your listening at each level by providing practical tools and techniques to transform your approach to communication. Embrace this journey to become not just a better manager, but a leader who truly listens and understands.

Alina Florea

Your Management Performance Coach

 Summary:

The guide begins by acknowledging a common workplace issue: dominant voices overshadowing others. It emphasizes the importance of listening skills for managers in any organizational position. Oscar Stromboli's book, 'How to Listen' is referenced, presenting the idea that effective listening involves actively transforming one's perspective, moving beyond just understanding words to engaging actively and intentionally in conversations. The guide addresses common misconceptions about listening, such as it being passive, automatic, uniform, innate, and secondary to speaking. These beliefs hinder effective leadership and team cohesion.

It then explores Stromboli's levels of listening, detailing how each can be mastered and implemented in various managerial roles. The goal is to shift from being a manager who merely hears to one who truly listens.

The Five Levels of Listening:

Level 1 - Self-Awareness: Focus on personal readiness and attention in communication.

Level 2 - Content: Understanding verbal and non-verbal cues.

Level 3 - Context: Grasping the broader situational and relational background of conversations.

Level 4 - Unsaid: Interpreting silence and unexpressed elements in communication.

Level 5 - Meaning: Discerning deeper intentions and motivations behind words.

Each level is analyzed and explained through examples that managers can immediately recognise from their activity. In addition, it is explicitly shown what can go wrong at each level.

Coaching is offered as a certain way for management improvement and the article highlights how can it be used as a tool for refining listening skills. The benefits are obvious in terms of leadership impact: improved listening enhances leadership effectiveness, decision-making, and team dynamics.

In the end, the article encourages self-reflection about your listening skills and the pursuit of coaching for professional growth.